Why This Comparison Matters Fishing is one of North America’s most popular outdoor activities, with anglers spending over $7 billion annually on gear and bait. Choosing the wrong method can lead to: This guide provides data-driven insights to help you decide which method works best for your needs. 1. Catch Rate Comparison: Which Method Lands More Fish? Artificial Lures (Lure Fishing) ✅ Pros: ❌ Cons: Live Bait Fishing ✅ Pros: ❌ Cons: 📊 Catch Rate Data (North American Fishing Survey) Species Artificial Lure Success Live Bait Success Largemouth Bass 68% 52% Trout 45% 72% Catfish 30% 85% Northern Pike 75% 50% Conclusion: Lures excel for predatory fish, while live bait works better for cautious species. 2. Cost Comparison: Which Is Cheaper Long-Term? (2024 Data) Initial Setup Costs Item Artificial Lures Live Bait Rod $50-$150 $30-$100 Reel $40-$120 $20-$60 Bait/Lures $30-$100 (reusable) $10-$20 per trip Total $120-$370 $60-$180 + recurring bait costs 5-Year Cost (Fishing 30x/Year) Method Initial Cost Annual Cost